Technology readiness levels (TRL): what they mean and why funding calls ask for them
The Technology Readiness Level (TRL) is a scale from 1 to 9 that measures how far a technology has come, from observing its basic principles (TRL 1) to a system proven to work in its real operational environment (TRL 9). The scale was developed by NASA; today EU research programmes and many R&D funding calls use it to describe where a development project starts and where it is meant to end.
By Péter TakácsPublished:
The nine TRL levels
Following the definitions used in the European Commission's research programmes, in brief:
- TRL 1 – basic principles observed
- TRL 2 – technology concept formulated
- TRL 3 – experimental proof of concept
- TRL 4 – technology validated in the lab
- TRL 5 – technology validated in a relevant environment
- TRL 6 – technology demonstrated in a relevant environment
- TRL 7 – system prototype demonstrated in an operational environment
- TRL 8 – system complete and qualified
- TRL 9 – actual system proven in an operational environment
Why do funding calls ask for it?
TRL gives applicants and evaluators a shared language. It shows whether a project is closer to research or to development, how much technical risk it carries, and whether what it promises by the end is realistic. Many calls specify which starting and target levels they fund, so an application has to state both and back them up.
Typically, fundamental research sits at the lower levels (TRL 1–3), prototypes and experimental development in the middle and upper levels (roughly TRL 4–8), and market launch heads towards TRL 9. The exact expectations are always set by the specific call.
How do you determine a project's TRL?
The question is always what evidence you already have. A good idea and calculations are only a concept; a sample working in the lab is around TRL 4; if the prototype has also been tested in conditions resembling real use, that's TRL 5–6.
A common mistake is overestimating the level, for example treating a sample that worked once in the lab as a finished prototype. A realistic starting level makes the application more credible and the project schedule more achievable.
What to keep in mind when planning the project
Tie milestones to TRL levels: each step up should come with concrete, measurable evidence (a measurement, test or demonstration). That makes progress easy to follow in the reports, and at the end it's clear what has been achieved.
Frequently asked questions
What does TRL stand for?
Technology Readiness Level: a scale from 1 to 9 describing how mature a technology is.
Can a project move up several TRL levels?
Yes. Most R&D projects aim to move from a starting level to a higher one, for example from lab validation (TRL 4) to a prototype demonstrated in an operational environment (TRL 7).
Does TRL apply to software?
Yes, although it was originally designed for hardware systems. For software, the relevant and operational environments mean, for example, testing with real data and real users.